We have the most effective Thanksgiving pie recipes—and two good crust recipes—for an incredible pie-baking day.
Ah, pie season! While different desserts reign supreme all through the remainder of the 12 months, the vacation season (and particularly, Thanksgiving) is prime pie season. To make your vacation menu as straightforward as will be, we’ve pulled collectively our absolute best Thanksgiving pies for you to select from. All these treats have been kitchen-tested to verify they’re top-notch for serving to your whole vacation company. Let’s get baking!
How many Thanksgiving pies do I want?
We’re of the sturdy private perception that there isn’t any such factor as “too much pie.” This applies on a regular basis, however significantly on Thanksgiving!
Typically, a 9-inch pie will be sliced into 6-8 slices—relying on the richness of the filling. Since Thanksgiving is a meals vacation, many of us will take pleasure in multiple slice (particularly you probably have a number of forms of pie to pattern), so we suggest planning on no less than two slices per individual.
For a small group (beneath 10 folks), which means we suggest no less than two pies. For a bigger group, plan on having one pie for each 5 or so folks.
At Thanksgiving, the place the meals is plentiful and also you most likely have a smorgasbord of Thanksgiving desserts, you’ll be able to sometimes get by with slicing pies into even smaller servings—10 slices per pie or much more. This permits of us to take a pattern measurement slice of pie to style every dessert on the desk.
What type of Thanksgiving pies ought to I serve?
For dessert, supply a set of pies with a wide range of taste profiles and textures—that approach, you’ll have one thing for everybody! Here are the basic classes to select from. Use these classes as your information, and select one from every for a very well-rounded dessert cart.
Custard Pies. A basic round Thanksgiving! Custard pies have creamy fillings sometimes set with eggs (however not at all times). This is the place you’ll discover Thanksgiving favorites resembling pumpkin pie, candy potato pie, and sugar cream pie.
Fruit Pies. Apple pie is the basic alternative right here, however cranberry pie and pear pie are additionally fall fruits that may make an incredible pie! Or should you canned pie filling this summer time, you don’t should be restricted to what’s in season—should you love a cherry pie, go for it.
Nutty Pies. The crunch of a nut-based pie could be a good distinction to easy and creamy custard-based or pumpkin pies. We love a bourbon pecan pie, however there are many walnut- or hazelnut- primarily based pies on the market too.
Chocolate Pies. It’s the uncommon one that doesn’t love one thing chocolate-y to spherical out their meal. French silk pie, chocolate chess pie, and even pies with chocolate chips will match the invoice right here.
Make positive to refill on sweetened whipped cream for serving together with your pies! You could make your individual simply, however when serving to a crowd, it tends to be less complicated simply to seize the canned stuff and set it out by your dessert desk.
When ought to I bake my pies?
If you’re attempting to get forward so that you don’t should do all of your cooking and baking on Thanksgiving itself, dessert is a superb course to prep forward of time.
If you don’t wish to assemble and bake the complete pie prematurely, even getting the dough for the pie crust made prematurely might help lower down on Thanksgiving dishes and time within the kitchen on Turkey Day. Pie dough will be wrapped in plastic wrap and refrigerated for as much as 3 days, or frozen for as much as 3 months (should you can prep for the vacation that far prematurely, extra energy to you!).
Fruit-based pies can usually be saved lined on the counter for as much as three days, so go forward and bake these prematurely. Pies which are custard-based or in any other case include numerous eggs and dairy of their filling will must be saved within the fridge. If you even have a turkey and substances for aspect dishes in your fridge, there might not be room for these pies—as a substitute, you’ll wish to freeze them or make them on the day of. More on that subsequent!
Pies are an incredible merchandise in your Thanksgiving to-do record to delegate! When somebody asks, “Can I bring anything to dinner?” fortunately take them up on their supply to assist and ask them to carry a pie.
Can you freeze Thanksgiving pies?
Generally, sure, however some pies will freeze higher than others.
Pies which are custard-based might have texture adjustments once they come out of the freezer, so we suggest protecting something with a creamy custard filling out of the freezer. We’ve had okay luck with freezing Pumpkin Pie and Sweet Potato Pie, however solely after we freeze after baking. The texture adjustments barely, however not sufficient to scrap the pie.
Fruit pies, usually, are glorious within the freezer—you may make them months forward of time, freeze them unbaked, after which have them able to go for Thanksgiving.
We suggest freezing fruit pies unbaked—simply assemble the pie in an aluminum foil pie plate, cowl, and freeze as is. When it’s time to bake, no must defrost. Just uncover and pop within the oven. Add about 20-Half-hour to the unique baking time.
Now that we’ve lined all that, let’s transfer on to the pies themselves!
Best Pie Crust Recipes
We extremely suggest beginning off your Thanksgiving baking with do-it-yourself pie crust. It’s not that tough or time-consuming, it saves money, and the flavour and texture are far superior in comparison with these of premade crusts! Over a number of years and numerous trials, we’ve developed two pie crust recipes that may work for almost any pie:
Perfect Pie Crust—This pie crust has been used to create hundreds of pies throughout the globe! It’s flaky, it’s tender, and it’s a breeze to drag collectively.
Gluten-Free Pie Crust—We examined our gluten-free pie crust recipe for months earlier than publishing it. You can serve this pie crust to anybody at your vacation desk with out them understanding it’s gluten-free!
Our Favorite Thanksgiving Pies
These are the pies that we serve at our circle of relatives Thanksgivings, and we’ve obtained a little bit one thing for everybody!
Pumpkin Pie—If you’re solely going to choose one pie to serve at Thanksgiving, that is it! Our pumpkin pie recipe has been handed down for generations, and it’s obtained a secret trick to creating it the creamiest, silkiest pumpkin pie you’ll ever style.
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie—Chocolate, bourbon, nuts—what’s to not love? This wealthy and decadent pie is nice served with after-dinner espresso.
Apple Pie—Pre-made apple pie filling makes pulling collectively a basic apple pie a breeze.
Caramel Apple Pie—This inventive twist on an apple pie elevates this basic Thanksgiving dessert into one thing decadent and pleasant!
Bourbon Vanilla Bean Apple Pie—Bourbon is a theme right here across the holidays, and this ready-to-use pie filling makes assembling your apple pie tremendous quick and simple.
Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie—A convention right here in Indiana! Sugar cream pie is a wealthy and silky pie that has a candy, buttery taste that everybody ought to take pleasure in, irrespective of the place they dwell.
Sweet Potato Pie—If you’re over the entire pumpkin spice factor, candy potato pie is perhaps your savior! Tender candy potatoes are mixed with spices like nutmeg and cinnamon to make a thick and wealthy filling.
Cranberry Curd Tart—This cranberry pie is as stunning as it’s scrumptious! The crust is an easy pressed crust constructed from floor almonds, and the filling is tangy and candy cranberry curd. This is a superb pie for Thanksgiving or Christmas!
Chocolate Chess Pie—This chocolate cream pie is for chocolate fanatics solely! It’s wealthy, it’s thick, and it’s the right option to cap off a scrumptious Thanksgiving dinner.
Coconut Cream Pie—This would possibly sound like a little bit of an odd duck to placed on a Thanksgiving record, however we’ve discovered that having a little bit bit of various taste from the closely spiced tastes of the season could be a good break!